Why Toll Roads in Toronto are not such a bad idea….

iStock_000001210857XSmallHere me out on this:

First….most of the great large cities in the world have excellent Subways and rail lines. Toronto slowed and almost stopped building Subways and rapid transit years ago and we became more and more dependent on highways for transportation.

Second…Toronto is surrounded by bedroom communities filled with people who use the major thoroughfares to come to the City to make their incomes and head back to their suburban properties where they pay the most of their taxes. Some major cities like New York make suburbanites who get paid in the City, pay a special tax to the City of New York.

Third…and most important…even though it is difficult, cars have made it easier to live in one part of the City, work in another part of the City or Province and recreate in yet another part of the City or Province. We think nothing of doing so because the cost  is relatively cheap.

Maybe a toll on the major City owned highways during peak hours will make us think more about living closer to work, telecommuting or travelling the highways at non-peak times:

  • The 407 Highway sits at the top of the City and if you’re in a rush and choose to use it, it is a great option.
  • Houston, Texas has a circle of freeways surrounding the City that has one lane that is a “Pay-Express” lane.
  • It’s cheaper to fly on Porter Airlines on off peak hours…

With all, the consumer can make a decision. If you have to travel the major arteries at peak hours, you pay. I will happily do so if I know that we will start building major Subways again.

I salute Sarah Thompson, candidate for Mayor of  Toronto City Council, for bringing the subject to the political table. Chances are it will never happen because it is a “hot potato” but it is something that we should be thinking about.

Your thoughts?

4 Responses

  1. Chris Larsen

    I believe you may be misinformed. According to your second paragraph, the people who commute downtown for work aren’t paying taxes to the city, but according to a recent article in the Toronto Sun, the surrounding suburbs have been paying a tax to the City of Toronto for years.

    Also, for all the talk I have heard of Toll Roads, no one has ever suggested that those tolls only occur during rush hour, they’re talking about tolls on the DVP 24-7.

  2. Richard Silver Post author

    The New York Tax is based on income. Now that the Province has reduced their committment to Transit City, Toll Roads may have to become a reality. My suggestion is that by tolling roads during certain hours you may move more use to off hours and lessen congestion by doing so…

  3. Richard Silver Post author

    Thanks for your comments Sarah and for bringing this to the table to be discuseed. It is an option that must be looked at in the coming years…Best Wishes in your run for Mayor!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *